Understanding the New Independent Contractor Classification Rules and I-9 Form Requirements

The United States Department of Labor (DOL) has enacted new standards for defining independent contractor status under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), effective March 11, 2024. These changes signify a notable shift from the previous administration’s guidelines, critically impacting the preparation of I-9 FORMS for workforce management in the U.S.

Background: From 2021 Rule to 2024 Final Rule

The Trump administration’s 2021 Rule simplified the classification of workers as independent contractors, focusing mainly on workers’ control over their work and profit or loss risks. Contrastingly, the 2024 Final Rule, announced on January 9, 2024, rescinds these standards in favor of a more encompassing “totality of the circumstances” approach. This revision could lead to more workers being classified as employees rather than independent contractors.

The Economic Realities Test

Reinstating the economic realities test, the Final Rule assesses the relationship between worker and employer through six primary factors:

  • Opportunity for Profit/Loss: The worker’s potential to earn or lose money based on their managerial skills.
  • Investments: Comparison of the worker’s and the employer’s investments in the work.
  • Permanence of Relationship: How long-lasting and stable the work relationship is.
  • Degree of Control: The level and nature of the employer’s control over the work.
  • Work’s Integral Nature: The significance of the work to the employer’s business.
  • Skill and Initiative: The worker’s level of skill and initiative.

These factors are not exhaustive and allow room for additional considerations, offering courts and agencies significant discretion.

Implications for I-9 FORM Compliance

A key aspect of the Final Rule is its implications for I-9 FORM compliance. While the I-9 FORM is mandatory for verifying the legal work authorization of employees in the U.S., it is not required for true “independent contractors.” This underscores the importance of accurately distinguishing between an independent contractor and a W-2 employee.

With the Final Rule, justifying independent contractor classifications may be more challenging, potentially increasing the number of workers requiring I-9 FORMS. Employers must reassess their workforce classifications to ensure compliance with both the new rules and I-9 FORM requirements.

Takeaway and Future Considerations

The Final Rule introduces a more stringent and comprehensive approach to worker classification, likely complicating the classification of workers as independent contractors. Employers should review their worker classifications to avoid legal and tax issues related to misclassification.

Employers must also stay informed about potential legal challenges or changes to these rules, as the Final Rule could face opposition from business groups and legislative efforts.


The implementation of the Final Rule necessitates a careful review of worker relationships and proactive compliance strategies. Employers are advised to consult legal experts to navigate these changes effectively, ensuring adherence to both the new classification standards and I-9 FORM requirements.

If you or your family members have any questions about how immigration and nationality laws in the United States may affect you, or if you want to access additional information about immigration and nationality laws in the United States or Canada, please do not hesitate to contact the immigration and nationality lawyers at NPZ Law Group. You can reach us by emailing info@visaserve.com or by calling us at 201-670-0006 extension 104. We also invite you to visit our website at www.visaserve.com for more information.